The TriStateFootball.com staff hand-picked the 2025 Preseason All-TSF First Team members, but asked for help from local high school football fans, players, and coaches in figuring out the rest of the team.
After two weeks, we’ve landed on quite a list of talent from 411 nominees from 116 schools down to a final count of 125 players. The “fan vote” accounted for 30 percent of the final vote with the TSF staff vote accounting for the difference.
Without further ado here’s our official 2025 Preseason All-TSF Team:
FIRST TEAM
OFFENSE
QB: Matt Ponatoski (Moeller)
RB: Devlan Daniel (Indian Hill)
RB: Ryder Hooks (Lakota East)
OL: Max Merz (Highlands)
OL: Kalel Johnson (Moeller)
OL: Justyn Lyles (Withrow)
OL: Tyrell Scott (Elder)
OL: Lual Aleu (Winton Woods)
WR: Ace Cooper (Middletown)
WR: Jamier Brown (Wayne)
TE: Landen Miree (Princeton)
ATH: Daniel Vollmer (St. Xavier)
K: Jon Hewitt (Eaton)
DEFENSE
DL: Christian Harris (Moeller)
DL: Jamarcus Whyce (Trotwood-Madison)
DL: Royce Rogers (Springfield)
LB: Cam Thomas (Lakota West)
LB: Brady Ballart (South Dearborn)
LB: Jacob Savage (Ryle)
LB: Kobe Clapper (St. Xavier)
LB: Derek Uran (Elder)
DB: Ace Alston (Anderson)
DB: Brayden Reilly (St. Xavier)
DB: Rihyael Kelley (Winton Woods)
RS: Eli Stewart (Wilmington)
P: Jacob Rudowski (Kings)
SECOND TEAM
OFFENSE
QB: Cam O’Hara (Cooper)
RB: Parker Johnson (Centerville)
RB:Kenyon Norman (Lakota West)
WR: Tyler Fryman (Beechwood)
WR: Aaron McFarland (Oak Hills)
TE: Cooper McCutchan (Moeller)
OL: Noah Brown (East Central)
OL: William Sandfoss (Newport Central Catholic)
OL: Grant Hester (St. Xavier)
OL: Mason Howard (Xenia)
OL: Patrick O’Brien (Moeller)
ATH: Jordan Vann (Middletown)
PK: Kofi Adubofuor (Lakota West)
DEFENSE
DL: DJ Singletary (Middletown)
DL: Reilly Newman (Lakoya West)
DL: Caillou Robinson (West Clermont)
LB: Aden Reeder (St. Xavier)
LB: Andre Parker Jr. (Princeton)
LB: Antwoine Higgins (Anderson)
LB: Colin Isaac (Tippecanoe)
DB: Drew Cripps (Alter)
DB: Darrius Dennis (Trotwood-Madison)
DB: Jamison Webster (Beavercreek)
DB: Taj Powell (Springfield)
P: Ben Sakach (Badin)
RET: Nathan Pabst (Beechwood)
THIRD TEAM
OFFENSE
QB: Shane Cole (Centerville)
RB: Landon Young (West Clermont)
WR: Troy Harris (Williamsburg)
WR: Zion Neal (Princeton)
WR: Josh Adelsperger (Harrison)
OL: Jack Harper (Springboro)
OL: Ryan Cable-Massie (Taylor)
OL: Paxton Tengesdahl (Wayne)
OL: Kavon Blackmon (Springfield)
OL: Bradan Bailey (Hamilton)
ATH: Dylan Lee (Ryle)
PK: Carson Lair (Beechwood)
DEFENSE
DL: Jeremiah Nash (Tortwood-Madison)
DL: Josh Fasbender (St. Xavier)
DL: Bryce Brewster (Taft)
LB: Jahmiere Daniels (Springfield))
LB: Max Rhodes (Oak Hills)
LB: Adam Kirtley (Taft)
LB: DJ Edwards (Lakota West)
DB: Ziere Alston (Centerville)
DB: Ben Markarian (Harrison)
DB: Hezikiah Kelley (Northwest)
DB: Nate Dawson (Winton Woods)
P: Parker Seibel (Northwest)
RET: Corbin Thackery (North Decatur)
HONORABLE MENTIONS
QB: Bryshawn Brown (Winton Woods), Kaden Estep (Elder), Cash Harney (Covington Catholic), Aiden Kirkpatrick (Troy), Rio Litmer (Highlands), Monanna Torbert (Taft), and Brady Young (New Richmond).
RB: Jacob Britt (St. Xavier), Mattias Brunicardi (Springboro), Logan Doty (Fairmont), Preston Flick (Harrison), Dylan Gaiser (Covington Catholic), Tyler Joselyn (Moeller), Keegan Maher (Cooper) and Ryan Minges (East Central).
WR/TE: Tyson Davis (Lakota West), Shawn Fishwick (Xenia), Josiah Gault (Wyoming), Eddie Holloway (Taft), Marcus Hughbanks (Batavia), Nick Lautar (Lebanon), Jaxon Long (Springboro) and Will Strong (Tippecanoe).
OL: Jeremy Bader (Oak Hills), Eli Caldwwell (Ryle), Carson Eshelman (Beechwood), AJ Graves (Batavia), Carl Lyttle (West Clermont), Jeffrey Martin (Tippecanoe), Joe Mulvey (McNicholas), GAvin Osterman (East Central) and William Sweeney (St. Xavier).
ATH: Dameyn Anness (Ludlow), Ninja Hill (Taft), Jackson Kauffman (Bishop Fenwick), Grant Langferman (Milan) and Cam Telinda (Goshen).
PK: Max Gogul (Mason), Jay Greenburg (Springboro), Jack Mallabar (Moeller) and Brady Stidham (Loveland).
DL: Eckley Bridges (Hamilton), Bo Gay (Ryle), Mason Holbrook (Hamilton), Javion Lewis (Wayne), Chayse Mack (Taft), Jaylen Mercer (Winton Woods), Charlie Parmer (North Decatur), Zane Richardson (Milan), Brady Seely (Centerville), Logan White (Harrison) and Jameer Whyce (Trotwood-Madison).
LB: Preston Allen (Springfield), Cesar Berryman (Valley View), CJ Bryant (Middletown), Raymir Coney (Princeton), Brycen Deller (Harrison), Alex Dugan (Elder), Pete Fortkamp (Elder), Kobe Lewis (Fairfield), Luke Mullinger (Centerville), Owen Pitzer (Covington Catholic) and Kinser Pope (Lawrenceburg).
DB: Ryker Campbell (Cooper), Mark Madden (Anderson), Logan Sanning (Covington Catholic), Ricky Thomas (Withrow), Andrew Wells (Princeton), Kavonte Whipple (Taft) and Gane Williams (Highlands).
RET: Carson Khayo (Moeller), Jordan Pendleton (Simon Kenton) and William Wilson (Dunbar).
P: Henry Feltman (Turpin).
+++
TOP VOTE GETTERS BY POSITION
QB: Brady Young (New Richmond)
RB: Tyler Joselyn (Moeller)
WR/TE: Jaxon Long (Springboro)
OL: Carson Eshelman (Beechwood)
DL: Reilly Newman (Lakota West)
LB: Brycen Deller (Harrison)
DB: Drew Cripps (Alter)
K: Jack Mallabar (Moeller)
P: Henry Feltman (Turpin)
ATH: Cam Telinda (Goshen)
RET: Carson Khayo (Moeller)
TOP 18 VOTE GETTERS OVERALL
1. Tyler Josleyn (Moeller) – 7,393
2. Preston Flick (Harrison) – 6,562
3. Carson Eshelman (Beechwood) – 4,883
4. Noah Brown (East Central) – 4,709
5. Cam Telinda (Goshen) – 4,293
6. Brady Young (New Richmond) – 2,933
7. Jackson Kauffman (Bishop Fenwick) – 2,685
8. Carl Lyttle (West Clermont) – 2,634
9. Reilly Newman (Lakota West) – 2,010
10. Brycen Deller (Harrison) – 1,960
11. Shane Cole (Centerville) – 1,932
12. Zane Richardson (Milan) – 1,912
13. Caillou Robinson (West Clermont) – 1, 699
14. Luke Mullinger (Centerville) – 1,480
15. Jaxon Long (Springboro) – 1,255
16. Drew Cripps (Alter) – 1,227
17. Aiden Kirkpatrick (Troy) – 1,198
18. Brady Seely (Centerville) – 1,116
